O'Shae Sibley Wiki - O'Shae Sibley Biography On Monday, a guy who was fatally stabbed in an alleged anti-gay attack in Brooklyn was recalled as a gifted and promising dancer, according to law enforcement officials. A 17-year-old high school student is reportedly wanted in connection with the killing. A friend who was there during the stabbing said that O'Shae Sibley, 28, was allegedly stabbed because he was "vogueing" to Beyoncé's famous song "Renaissance" outside a petrol station in Coney Island on Saturday night. "They hated us because we are gay!" One of Sibley's pals, Otis Pena, vented in a Facebook post while posting graphic images of the murder. "[They were] screaming that we are Muslims and we detest homosexuals!" You all chose to stab one of us when we were just pumping petrol!" Around 11 p.m., Sibley was slain in a fight that broke out between two groups of men at a Mobil petrol station on Coney Island Avenue...